Energy secretary Ed Miliband at the Summit on the Future of Energy Security Conference in London, United Kingdom. (UK Government/Flickr)
In January, after much delay and reluctance, the British Government was forced to publish a summary of its national security assessment of the dangerous consequences of climate and ecological crisis. It was pretty devastating. Most striking was the straightforward statement on the first page:
“Ecosystem degradation is occurring across all regions. Every critical ecosystem is on a pathway to collapse (irreversible loss of function beyond repair).”
The confidence rating for this judgement was “High”.
What is most shocking about this statement is not that it is a new and unexpected finding; it’s that it comes from an official British Government publication, one based on the views of scientists, military planners, and security experts.
How to spin this? The press office at the Department for the Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (Defra) came up with this paragraph to introduce the online publication of the report:
“This assessment, which was developed by analysts and experts across HM Government, supports long-term resilience planning. Publishing the assessment highlights opportunities for innovation, green finance and global partnerships that can drive growth while safeguarding the ecosystems that underpin our collective security and prosperity.” (Emphasis added.)
Opportunities for growth!? That’s one way of looking at it. But the assessment lays bare the catastrophic consequences of profit-driven growth spiraling out of control. Governments can’t say they weren’t warned. For the past 50 years and more—the UN Environment Conference in Stockholm was in 1972—scientists and campaigners have foreseen the outcomes that are becoming all too apparent now, particularly spiralling weather conditions.
Let us be blunt. It is truly extraordinary—to the point of absurdity—to try to spin a report warning of the likely collapse of civilisation as a growth opportunity, especially when that very growth is causing the collapse of this civilisation!
It is as if, in 1939, there had been a government report on the rise of Nazi Germany and the spin-doctors had tried to explain it away as primarily an opportunity for ‘recovery’ from the recession. But even that analogy understates the nauseating character of the line emphasised above. To make the analogy more exact, it would have to be that such growthism was a leading cause of the rise of Nazism! Of course, that makes no sense. Which is the point: What Defra has said here is worse, even crazier, than if, in 1939, there had been a government report on the rise of Nazi Germany that didn’t focus overwhelmingly on the national security case for rearmament.
It is awful and mad and a sign of the times that Defra did not present the National Security Assessment on Ecosystem Collapse overwhelmingly as a case for addressing the national security crisis that climate and ecological collapse has become.
The British Government wants to show it is keen to protect its citizens. However, it is doing this in two ways that reflect its insecurity and ambivalence, as it is torn between facing up to reality and trying not to let the public become too worried.
So we have this summary national security report eventually published, but at the same time the summary excludes many of the more alarming findings in the full assessment. For example, about the vulnerability of UK food supplies and the pandemic threats from melting permafrost releasing toxic bacteria and viruses. The gaps in the summary were highlighted in a really impressive, must-watch ITV News report.
While the summary was published in January of this year following a Freedom of Information request from the Green Alliance think tank, the National Security Assessment (NSA) had originally been scheduled for publication in Autumn 2025. The Times reported that 10 Downing Street stalled publication of the report because it feared it was too negative. Our speculation is that part of the reason for this suppression is that the NSA itself delivered a blow against government policy aimed at growth at the expense of nature. To make matters worse: the full, unpublished version of the part-suppressed National Security Assessment itself draws a link between the damage to nature that is going on (worldwide) and likely severe damage to the UK economy. A savage irony, for growth-fixated governments.
Make it make sense!
Of course, deeper thinking here reveals a twisted way in which it makes a kind of sense. The NSA mainly concerns the impact on Britain of nature- and climate-degradation worldwide. Most of which is very much beyond Britain’s control (though not, of course, entirely beyond some potential smart British influence). The brutal reality, which tells us much about the savage, multiply-nested collective action tragedy we are stuck pretty deep in, is that there is a certain logic to being complicit in the destruction of the world, even though it harms everyone’s economies, if what one is trying to do is focally to keep up with the other countries whose economies are (along with one’s own country) perpetuating the harm.
So, while we find the spin from Defra, on which we have centred this article, deeply reprehensible and, in a direct sense, self-destructive, we also understand where it is coming from. It tells us that we need a profound worldwide change in how we organise human life on Earth. And we had better also prepare for the possibility that that change might not be forthcoming: i.e., we also need a Plan B.
Talking of which: The latest development in Britain is that we now have a set of government warnings to be ready for emergencies. However, the explanations given about the possible causes of these don’t mention the climate and ecological crisis! And of course, there’s no trace of the national security assessment in this context. All the information it’s apparently safe to know is in this national “Be informed about hazards” guideline.






Comments