Society

The homes that stick with us

November 20, 2026

This summer, I met a young man who moved 2,000+ miles away to attend an east coast college. It was not long before he was (unexpectedly) homesick for his home state.

Like him, I left Idaho for college on the east coast when I was eighteen. And I ached for the community and place I’d left behind. My loss of the West pulled me to attention. Why did leaving my hometown hurt more than I had anticipated?

Loss exposes terrain in our interior landscape that we took for granted. I think we each have an inner map of belonging: whether made up of friends, kin, geography, institutions, or some combination of all four. But we often don’t pay attention to that map until we’ve veered off course. As homesickness hits, we know where we are—and where we wish to be.

Idaho is part of me in a very unique way. I have realized over time that I don’t feel homesick for every place I’ve lived in, even places I lived in for a very long time. Others I have talked to express similar feelings. Even those who have moved multiple times often have a place or two that truly hold a “home” ache. It begs the question: what makes certain places “stick” with us? What magic do they hold, which draws them to mind and not others?

I started puzzling out a set of criteria that I submit to you for consideration and conversation. My hunch is that places need to have at least two of three “ingredients” to be what I’m calling a “sticky place.” A “sticky place” has a long-term influence or presence on the human soul. It has a pull that lasts through the years. Even if or when you move away, you keep thinking about it. You miss it as the seasons change. You do what you can to go back and visit, whenever you can.

These places can still have tons of problems. (I think all places do.) The place’s stickiness does not negate or patch over the problems. But if it’s truly a “sticky” place, you want to fight the problems and restore what’s broken, rather than just shrugging your shoulders and leaving.

The three strongest “pulls” I have felt on my own heart and soul from sticky places fall generally into these three categories:

  1. Nature (the actual landscape is lovely and somehow unique; not talking about architecture here, just the flora, fauna, and topography)
  2. Culture (people have built vibrant, interconnected, hospitable, supportive institutions and traditions; this isn’t just about consumer culture, like good restaurants, but about the way people truly live together and support each other)
  3. Built environment (the way streets, sidewalks, roads, human-cultivated green space, and buildings interact with each other is supportive of human wellbeing and connection; it is also, importantly, beautiful)

I think very few places get a full 3/3 score on this. But I think they need at least 2/3 to be a sticky place. I’ve attached a Venn diagram below for your viewing pleasure (and critique). Note that the the + and – sections note some tendencies of places that are in that zone of 2/3… they are not meant to describe every place. Many rural communities are diverse (and growing increasingly so). Some cities have more accessibility to green space and local food sovereignty than neighboring rural areas. These are just some potential problems that can come up when places are strong in certain areas but weak in others.

A few other things I began wondering about as I thought about the above intersections:

  • Places without a vibrant culture—even if they have a lovely built environment and beautiful natural landscapes—won’t survive as true places, at least not for very long… they’re the sorts of places that are getting built nowadays, and I’m very curious whether the culture piece will come with time, or not. How do we strengthen spaces that start beautiful, but have no strong communal institutions holding them together?
  • Cities and rural spaces tend to have their own strengths and unique “stickiness” because they hit 2/3 of the above—and are often quite strong on the “culture” piece. This thought, coupled with the above observation, affirms my belief that culture is always the transcendent piece. The two others may not be equally important, but rather subsidiary factors that balance or heighten the impact of the first. (This means the Venn diagram above… shouldn’t be a Venn diagram. Oh, well.)
  • On the other hand, what I’ve noticed about Idaho is that its natural landscape and cultural landscape are both quite strong—strong enough to help counterbalance the dearth of strong built environment in its sprawl. But over time, I wonder whether a weak built environment might actually weaken a place’s cultural environment—and that could have very dangerous consequences in places like Boise, and elsewhere. This would suggest that even if the other two factors are subservient to culture, they do influence the waxing or waning of a cultural landscape over time.
  • Are there any places that hit all three? If so, do they achieve a stickiness that is truly unique, or super-powerful? Perhaps so. One of the few places I’ve lived that seems to perhaps have the perfect “marriage” of the three is Oxford. It contained geographic beauty, a strong built environment (fantastic walkability, even if we ignore the splendor of its architecture), and a very vibrant culture. And even though I only lived there for a year, it has held an extra “sticky” place in my soul. I can’t shake it, and I miss it often.
  • I am guessing there is still a magic ingredient that I have not been able to identify yet. Something we humans struggle to put into words. If you have a hunch as to what it might be, share it with me! I’m going to laugh at myself if it’s super obvious.

What if we live in a place that has only one of these things—or none? And we cannot move? Can we influence any of the above three factors, and help build “stickier” spaces?

People have been building home for as long as humans have been around. They do this by going to town hall meetings, advocating for sidewalks (in the right places), and caring for public parks. They do this by picking up trash on the street. They do it by advocating for the rights of their neighbors. They do it by starting local clubs, associations, churches, or musical ensembles. They do it by growing gardens, planting trees, and bringing cookies to an elderly neighbor.

In addition to these outward-facing things, however, I think all the above—including the Venn diagram—could also apply in a smaller sense to our homes. Even in places that are more hostile toward longevity and richness, I think we can build strong homes that have a resonance, a “stickiness,” that multiplies outwards.

  • Cultivate a home that is beautiful: rich with texture, color, plant life, music, and art. This isn’t about spending lots of money, but rather about thinking about a home’s relationship to color, shape, proportion, texture, and order.
  • Make your home hospitable and open—to neighbors, community, friends, and family. Host game nights, pizza + movie nights, afternoon coffee with an elderly neighbor, brunch for hungry college students, book clubs, etc.
  • Plant lots of things, and try to plant lots of native things, when and where you can. As mentioned above, you could build a wildlife habitat in front of your house, or in the back garden. Plant berry bushes for the birds and the kids, trees for the next generation, and bright flowers for summer bouquets.

These are just a collection of thoughts on all the varied things that are helping our minds and souls feel connected to a place and its community of human beings and creatures. It’s far from complete (I haven’t even touched on farming, which seems like an important aspect of identity and “stickiness” in rural places!). But I am eager to hear your thoughts, pushback, ideas, and stories. Often, we get farther with these ideas when we share them. And so I look forward to learning from you in the days to come.

Reading List for more ideas on place and flourishing:

Grace Olmstead

Grace Olmstead is a journalist and author of Uprooted: Recovering the Legacy of the Places We’ve Left Behind. Her writing has been published in The American Conservative, The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Wall Street Journal, and others. A native of rural Idaho, she now lives outside Washington, DC, with her husband and three children.


Tags: Building Community

Forum

Visit the Resilience Community Forum today to join conversations on topics you care about. Share ideas and resources, make connections, and help create momentum on important issues.

Go to Forum

Comments

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted