Building a world of
resilient communities.



In small groups and small towns, opposition to Citizens United spreads

capitol sold by Brendan Hoffman

Activists rally for a constitutional amendment overturning theCitizens United Supreme Court decision. (Photo by Brendan Hoffman)

Jennifer Robinson describes herself as an introvert. “I’m not really the kind of person who likes doing presentations,” she says. But on January 23, Jennifer found herself in front of the Greenbelt, MD, city council and dozens of community members, proposing a resolution in support of an amendment to overturn the Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission Supreme Court decision.

“I really had to work myself up to do it,” she says. “But seeing all the other people there supporting this cause was so exciting. And the city council passed the resolution unanimously! They sent a letter to our state legislature supporting a Constitutional amendment.”

Jennifer is part of a “Resilience Circle” in Greenbelt that meets to learn about the economy and the environment, engage in mutual aid, and take social action. Like many others meeting across the country, her circle used a free seven-session curriculum as a guide for its initial meetings. Jennifer’s circle is sponsored by Greenbelt Climate Action Network (a project of in partnership with Simplicity Matters Earth Institute.

“Neither of us had any experience doing that kind of thing... But we supported each other and figured it out. It was amazing to have success so quickly.”

“It’s amazing how a Resilience Circle can bring out the social action ‘fever’ in a person,” reflects Lore Rosenthal, a member of another circle in Greenbelt. “It’s partly from learning about how corporations control our democracy—that makes people mad. But the support of the circle is what keeps them engaged in the long term. I think it’s that sustained energy that has caught on in our community. Lots of others have caught the fever—and it’s great!”

In December and January, Lore and Eugenia Kalnay, a climate scientist from Greenbelt, helped organize house parties in Greenbelt as part of a national campaign focused on overturning Citizens United. The parties drew in members of the Resilience Circles as well as the wider community, and folks talked about local, state, and federal strategies to overturn the decision.

Jennifer attended two of the parties. “A man from the Sierra Club talked about how he can’t accomplish any of his goals because of Citizens United and abusive corporate power,” she says. “I was really moved by that, because protecting and caring for the environment is near and dear to me.”

Jennifer teamed up with Eugenia to approach their city council about Citizens United. “Neither of us had any experience doing that kind of thing,” Jennifer says. “But we supported each other and figured it out. It was amazing to have success so quickly.”

The day after the Greenbelt city council agreed to send their letter to state officials, nearby College Park approved a similar letter, due to the efforts of another Resilience Circle member from that area. Greenbelt and College Park join about a dozen other municipalities that have passed measures opposing Citizens United, including the biggest American cities—New York City and Los Angeles—as well as small cities like Athens, OH, and Portland, ME. States like New Mexico and Montana have also taken steps to show their opposition.

“I think what we’re doing is creating momentum,” says Jennifer. “I believe in the concept of tipping points, and that these local actions are contributing to a larger movement.” Jennifer and others in her group may work their way up to lobbying state or even federal officials about overturning Citizens United, but for the moment, she says, “it feels really good to have done something, even if it’s a small thing.”

Lore and Jennifer agree that the small-group dynamic in a circle complements the experience of being part of a movement and attending large rallies or meetings. The small group, or “affinity group,” has been a crucial part of many social movements, and people are increasingly realizing its relevance for today. Organizers at Occupy Boston, for example, have been working to form affinity groups.

“It can sometimes be hard to get a group of activists to pull away from a political or social agenda,” says Lore. “But I always promise people that if you take five or six sessions focused on getting to know each other, you won’t be sorry. You’ll become much more effective activists. And you’ll also have fun in the process.”

Sarah ByrnesSarah Byrnes wrote this article for YES! Magazine, a national, nonprofit media organization that fuses powerful ideas with practical actions. Sarah is the organizer for the Common Security Clubs at the Institute for Policy Studies. She has worked with Americans for Fairness in Lending, Americans for Financial Reform, and the Thomas Merton Center.

YES! Magazine encourages you to make free use of this article by taking these easy steps. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License

What do you think? Leave a comment below.

Sign up for regular Resilience bulletins direct to your email.

Take action!  

Find out more about Community Resilience. See our COMMUNITIES page
Start your own projects. See our RESOURCES page.
Help build resilience. DONATE NOW.


This is a community site and the discussion is moderated. The rules in brief: no personal abuse and no climate denial. Complete Guidelines.

Lived Crisis vs. Systemic Crisis: Notes on a "New Narrative"

A new narrative will need to be prickly enough to resist easy incorporation, …

Epiconomics 102 : The Sunlight Economy

The adoption of The Paris Agreement by 195 countries on December 12, 2015 …

Becoming Bluegill

Staying put fosters both conservation and conversation with place.

Resilience + Resistance: A Recipe for Justice and Sustainability

In the face of climate change, we have the dual challenge of both resisting …

Of Sun, Rain, and Anti-Utilitarianism: A Review of "Degrowth"

If the degrowth movement is going to get traction on the mass level, …

Pre-publication review of The Harrows of Spring by James Howard Kunstler

And so it ends. With The Harrows of Spring, James Howard Kunstler officially …

Why I Strongly Support Bike Paths, Which I Basically Never Use

The past week or two have been good ones for bicycling in Wichita.