Building a world of
resilient communities.



Peak oil: Not an environmental silver bullet

Something's been bugging me about peak oil, and today we got a letter to the editor that crystallized it. I put it below the fold -- give it a read.

It's this: Environmentalists seem to have a somewhat naive faith that once the concept of peak oil sinks in, people will move -- as though by the force of tides -- to support renewable, decentralized energy.

But why should that be true? A much more natural, predictable reaction would be to push like mad for more drilling and for more coal gasification. Both more drilling and more coal-to-liquid-fuel production would fit better with our existing infrastructure and practices, however environmentally malign they may be.

The economics of peak oil will scare and motivate people, but there's no particular reason the environmental aspects of it will grip them. You know?

Anyway, read the letter.

Re: Take a Peak, Main Dish, by Amanda Griscom Little, Nov 3 2005

If only Matthew Simmons were right, environmentalists would have a stable platform for crusading for fuel conservation, huge investment in oil alternatives, and a major restructuring of our economy and society. Unfortunately, the peak oil hypothesis is desperately naive about oil alternatives and infrastructure.

The technology already exists for turning coal into oil or natural gas on a scale that will be more than adequate to offset the decline of conventional oil and gas supplies. Even without considering numerous renewable alternatives, the vast coal reserves would allow the fossil fuel economy to keep humming (or Hummering) with only a few years of marginally higher oil prices. Instead of worrying about rising oil prices, we should strategize about directing energy investor responses to high conventional oil prices.

Some will push to drill for oil everywhere. Others will seek investment in infrastructure to convert coal. Both parties will have the upper hand because their solutions are most compatible with our existing infrastructure. Interest in these activities is already evident in rapidly escalating exploratory drilling rates, massive investments in oil and tar-sand developments, and near record share prices for fossil energy companies.

This rush to fill the shortfall will lead to over-capacity. There will be a glut in the liquid fuels market, and the price of oil will not rise beyond $100 per barrel, but will fall towards the marginal cost of production from tar sands and coal -- $20-40 per barrel. Since tar sands and coal are far dirtier and more carbon-intensive than conventional oil, and low fuel prices will encourage consumption, this scenario would entail disastrous environmental and health impacts.

"Peak oil" represents not a crisis but a cross-roads. One path leads to energy production methods that are more environmentally destructive, but easier because of our existing infrastructure. The other realizes the promise of renewable alternatives and smart growth. When focused, environmental advocacy has been successful in helping society choose the right path. To do so here, we must recognize that "peak oil" brings both threats and opportunities, and will not alone define the right path. We're still living with a six-century fossil fuels legacy prompted by "peak wood" in the UK; it is time to make sure the path chosen now is more sustainable, socially and environmentally.

Kai M. A. Chan and Hadi Dowlatabadi
Institute for Resources, Environment & Sustainability

Editorial Notes: Several readers submitted this article, so it must have struck a nerve. On the basis of the news stories I've been monitoring, I think the diagnosis of the article is correct -- peak oil is no silver bullet. UPDATE: The Oil Drum has many comments on this article: On likely alternatives to conventional oil. -BA

What do you think? Leave a comment below.

Sign up for regular Resilience bulletins direct to your email.

Take action!  

Find out more about Community Resilience. See our COMMUNITIES page
Start your own projects. See our RESOURCES page.
Help build resilience. DONATE NOW.


This is a community site and the discussion is moderated. The rules in brief: no personal abuse and no climate denial. Complete Guidelines.

Review: 7 key scenes in Leonardo DiCaprio’s climate film Before the Flood

Before the Flood, a new feature-length documentary presented and produced by …

Transition in Cities  

It is widely assumed that the ongoing migration of rural peoples to …

Peak Oil Review: A Midweek Update - 20th Oct 2016

 A midweek update. This week’s EIA stocks report gave a …

Oil & Money: Tackling Corruption and Climate Change

This week, senior executives of the oil and gas industry will be meeting at …

CCC: UK must Act Now to Secure Zero-Carbon Heat by 2050

UK heating must be virtually zero-carbon by 2050, says the Committee on …

Peak Oil Review - Oct 17, 2016

 A weekly roundup of peak oil news, including: -Quote of the week …

Deepwater Horizon and our emerging 'normal' catastrophes

We think of the world we live in as static and linear rather than dynamic …