" />
Building a world of
resilient communities.



Peak oil in Shell's National Dialogue on Energy Security

Peak-oil related excerpts from Shell's National Dialogue on Energy Security, released in February.

Page 8-9

The Myth: We’re running out of oil.

The “peak oil” theory came up in nearly every market. While this wasn’t necessarily surprising, the pervasive nature of this strongly held belief was. Similarly, in a related survey that we conducted, more than half of the respondents said global oil production will peak within the next 20 years.13 This leads people to dismiss oil and gas from being part of the future energy portfolio. Also not surprisingly, we found that few people were aware of the scale of untapped domestic resources on the Outer Continental Shelf, or of the huge undeveloped unconventional resources, such as oil shale, oil sands and heavy oil.

The Reality: Oil resources are out there, should we choose to develop them.

When individuals think of peak oil, they tend to think that a sudden drop in global production follows soon thereafter. We don’t expect to see this on a global level. It is possible, though, that we will reach a plateau in the next few decades, followed by a gradual decline of conventional oil and gas production.

There is no shortage of molecules of oil and gas in the ground. However, there are multiple influences that will affect the pace at which this can, and will, be developed.

On the demand side, we are seeing a step-change in the growth of demand for energy, particularly as emerging economies, such as China and India, enter more energy-intensive phases in their economic development. It will be vital to become more efficient in how we use energy and to develop unconventional sources of oil and gas (such as oil sands), biofuels and vehicle electrification to meet this surge in demand. All energy sources added together will struggle to match demand – we will need all of the energy we can get.

On the supply side, many existing reservoirs are facing a natural decline in production. This means that high levels of continuous investment are required just to maintain status quo or to invest in enhanced oil recovery (EOR) techniques. In addition, ever-increasing levels of investment are required as smaller fields are developed and more complex frontier environments become the targets for hydrocarbon exploration and production, alongside the development of unconventional oil and gas supply. There are also uncertainties about the pace of investment in sensitive regions such as the Middle East and Latin America. Naturally, major resource-holding governments seek also to develop their sovereign reserves at a pace that matches their own economic goals.

There are plenty of uncertainties, which is why we explore future possibilities through scenarios. Looking at the oil picture, we find it misleading to think in terms of concepts like peak oil or try to put a timeframe to it. The significant economic point comes when tensions arise between the growth of global demand for energy and the pace of investment, production and supply. We believe we are entering such a period and will face this increasingly for some time to come.

Page 11

“Easy oil” will not keep up with demand. While we do not subscribe to the peak oil theory, the truth is that, particularly outside the Middle East, the readily accessible sources of conventional oil are being depleted. [28] To tap new resources requires hard choices. In some cases, that means spending more on exploration and development to find and tap ultra-deepwater resources as we are doing in the Gulf of Mexico. It means technology investments to convert oil sands to useable oil fluids as we are doing in Canada. And it means making the policy decisions necessary to grant access to areas where federal restrictions currently limit exploration and drilling.

Page 18

[13] In the town hall survey, 30 percent of respondents predicted global oil production would peak in less than 10 years; 28 percent predicted it would peak in 10-19 years. The general population responses were even higher: 33 percent and 35 percent respectively.

Editorial Notes: BA: To me, the most surprising thing in the report was the poll results, tucked away in the references. Two-thirds of Americans believe that peak oil will occur within 20 years, according to the Shell poll! Unfortunately the report doesn't give any details about the poll (size of sample, etc.), so one doesn't know how valid it is. The rest of the report was an interesting mixture of openness and the same old stuff. Much of the report is quite reasonable. Some of the explanations are tendentious, leaving out important details (such as the difficulties with oil shale and "clean coal"). Conservation and efficiency are mentioned, but dismissed. As the excerpts above show, Shell still hasn't 'fessed up to peak oil. It's the same old CERA doctrine of the "undulating plateau." Someday though, they will point with pride to Shell employee, M. King Hubbert, who developed the peak oil theory. Contributor Jerry McManus writes: My translation: "Peak oil? Phooey! There's plenty of oil, but boy howdy! It is going to be hard as heck to keep up with demand, after all, we're running as hard as we can just to keep the supply we've got now and it sure ain't getting any easier" End of easy abundant oil? Sounds a lot like the peak to me.

What do you think? Leave a comment below.

Sign up for regular Resilience bulletins direct to your email.

Take action!  

Find out more about Community Resilience. See our COMMUNITIES page
Start your own projects. See our RESOURCES page.
Help build resilience. DONATE NOW.


This is a community site and the discussion is moderated. The rules in brief: no personal abuse and no climate denial. Complete Guidelines.

Review: 7 key scenes in Leonardo DiCaprio’s climate film Before the Flood

Before the Flood, a new feature-length documentary presented and produced by …

Transition in Cities  

It is widely assumed that the ongoing migration of rural peoples to …

Peak Oil Review: A Midweek Update - 20th Oct 2016

 A midweek update. This week’s EIA stocks report gave a …

Oil & Money: Tackling Corruption and Climate Change

This week, senior executives of the oil and gas industry will be meeting at …

CCC: UK must Act Now to Secure Zero-Carbon Heat by 2050

UK heating must be virtually zero-carbon by 2050, says the Committee on …

Peak Oil Review - Oct 17, 2016

 A weekly roundup of peak oil news, including: -Quote of the week …

Deepwater Horizon and our emerging 'normal' catastrophes

We think of the world we live in as static and linear rather than dynamic …