Wendell Berry's weapons of mass destruction
I'm pretty sure that in his now-famous press briefing of Feb. 12, 2002, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld wasn't trying to write poetry in the vein of William Carlos Williams. Yet, how beautifully he captured the conundrum at the center of all human attempts to make sense of reality, helpfully set to verse by Slate:
As we know,
There are known knowns.
There are things we know we know.
We also know
There are known unknowns.
That is to say
We know there are some things
We do not know.
But there are also unknown unknowns,
The ones we don't know
We don't know.
Surely, in the history of literature, never have words more filled with humble awe at the limits of human knowing issued from the lips of an admitted torturer. It's a great irony, if you think about it in a certain way.
So that's why I like to imagine that, two years later, another poet of humility, who is also an avid student of irony, might have been inspired by the words of the Great Waterboarder.
"Except to the arrogantly ignorant, ignorance is not a simple subject," agrarian activist Wendell Berry wrote in a 2004 essay called "The Way of Ignorance" (available in a 2006 collection, The Way of Ignorance: And Other Essays).
If Rumsfeld is a man who tormented people and words alike, Berry is a man who would set them both free.
Berry, who brings a crafted prose style to essays on farming, religion, politics and the environment, has a way of making simple subjects fascinating and complex subjects understandable. In this essay, for example, he takes on no less a target than the practice of science, whose prestige and influence over industrial society are indisputable.
With peak oil threatening to take down the global economy and climate change threatening the future of the human species, Berry's remarks are more relevant today than ever before. Science helped cause these problems in the first place. Now, science helps us to understand each problem, yet, sound science is under constant political attack. If we can only cut through the politics and get back to the science, can it give us the solutions, if any exist?
Blinded me with science
It turns out that science has its own problems.
Berry is all for more science as long as he can frame it with intuition and traditional wisdom that he believes to be greater than science. Otherwise, science becomes just another form of "willful ignorance that refuses to honor as knowledge anything not subject to empirical proof...materialist ignorance."
This ignorance rejects useful knowledge such as traditions of imagination and religion, and so it comes across as narrow-mindedness. We have the materialist culture that afflicts us now because a world exclusively material is the kind of world most readily used and abused by the kind of mind the materialists think they have. To this kind of mind, there is not longer a legitimate wonder. Wonder has been replaced by a research agenda, which is still a world away from demonstrating the impropriety of wonder.
To this empirical ignorance, Berry joins moral ignorance, "the invariable excuse of which is objectivity," that refuses to make value judgments, as well as the ignorance of false confidence, which seems to be the attitude that has created a society of fools who rush in where angels fear to tread, whether with wars of choice or careless use of fossil fuels, both so beloved by Rumsfeld and his ilk.
Skeptical of large-scale solutions (Berry quotes a sarcastic Yeats: "Hurrah for revolution and more cannon shot! / A beggar upon horseback lashes a beggar on foot"), Berry's approach is not just the opposite of Rumsfeld's imperial overreach. Berry's is also not the angle you'd want to make a bundle saving the world by selling a billion electric cars or putting up a million wind turbines to power them in a clean energy revolution.
There is, as maybe we all have noticed, a conspicuous shortage of large-scale corrections for problems that have large-scale causes. Our damages to watersheds and ecosystems will have to be corrected one farm, one acre at a time. The aftermath of a bombing has to be dealt with one corpse, one wound at a time...Arrogance cannot be cured by greater arrogance, or ignorance by greater ignorance.
As he rejects heroic industrial interventions as arrogance, Berry finds that we are left only with "a proper humility" that he admits even he finds to be "laughable." How could small, local actions ever be big enough or fast enough to make a difference against the world's biggest problems?
Seeking big solutions to big problems, the eco-conscious search for "robust" and "scalable" solutions to climate change and peak oil employing our highest of high tech: nuclear fusion, algae fuel, thin-film solar panels, even geoengineering to remake the climate that we're now destroying. Fighting fire with fire.
Ignorance is bliss
It may be in human nature to try to help, especially if there's money to be made, Berry thinks. "To help, or to try to help, requires only knowledge; one needs to know promising remedies and how to apply them. But to do no harm involves a whole culture, and a culture very different from industrialism. It involves, at the minimum, compassion and humility and caution."
That may sound like too-little-too-late to those of us who'd like to see industrial society mobilized on a "war footing" to get off of fossil fuels, as green activists and peak oilers have called for in recent years. I've said this myself in countless conversations.
But now I'm starting to wonder if perhaps Berry has a point. Maybe we citizens of industrial nations should give up trying to help our world so much and instead learn to be satisfied with ceasing to cause so much harm. Maybe it's less about Apollo Projects, cool new clean energy sources, hot new systems to increase efficiency or brave new ways to use nanotechnology than about living with less stuff and enjoying life more.
If we decide to follow the path of acting locally and in harmony with the natural and cultural ecosystem where each of us find ourselves, then we will be following what Berry calls, after TS Eliot, "the way of ignorance."
Zen teachers call it "beginner's mind," but really it's just the path recommended by all great spiritual teachers, a way of faith with an active humility. Berry thinks it could be just what we need to set us free from bondage to the arrogance of the corporate mind that would process all nature into products or waste products and reduce all people to mere workers or consumers.
In that case, humility and living locally would become weapons of mass destruction -- weapons to destroy mass thinking -- that would be sure to evade Rummy's best efforts to hunt them down.
Erik Curren is the publisher of Transition Voice. He co-founded Transition Staunton Augusta in December 2009 and serves as managing partner of the Curren Media Group.
What do you think? Leave a comment below. See our commenting guidelines.
Sign up for regular Resilience bulletins direct to your email.