Peak Oil Review - November, 12th, 2007
1. Production and Prices
2. Economic Gloom
3. Peak Oil and the Media
4. IEA's World Energy Outlook 2007
5. Energy Briefs
1. Production and Prices
The struggle between the possibility of oil shortages this winter and fear of a demand-cutting recession continued last week. New York oil futures hit a new intraday high of $98.62. Prices are now up 57 percent over a year ago. The major news of the week was a storm in the North Sea which temporarily shut down oil production and the continued decline of US crude and gasoline stockpiles.
The US Energy Information Administration issued a forecast saying commercial oil inventories held by the world's major industrialized countries will fall below their five-year average at the end of 2007 and President Bush told at a news conference that oil prices are nearing $100 because of demand.
The week ahead promises to be a volatile one. Leading brokerage houses are predicting that oil will break $100 due to technical factors surrounding futures contracts and crude options that expire on Tuesday. Others see a collapse in prices immediately after the $100 level is reached.
The Thursday stocks report may reflect a drop in US imports and stockpiles due to the storms that shut-in a significant share of Mexico’s oil production two weeks ago.
2. Economic gloom
The outlook for the world economy came into sharper focus last week as stock markets on both sides of the Atlantic concluded their worst week in months and Federal Reserve Chairman Bernanke told Congress that the economy was going to get worse before it gets better. Although Bernanke gave no hint that interest rates would be lowered for a third time at the December 11th meeting, many on Wall Street are convinced that the economy will slow so much that Bernanke will be forced to make further cuts. Another rate cut would likely drive down the dollar still further and drive up gold and oil prices.
Despite assertions from Bernanke and other senior officials that the “overall economy remains resilient,” more are expressing concern that the economy, which has done well so far, cannot hold up indefinitely if oil prices remain in the vicinity of $100. The IMF, however, continues to say that record oil prices will push up inflation only marginally and will have little impact on economic growth.
Thus the heart of the matter is still the divide between those who see recent price increases as mostly speculation and those who perceive a fundamental change in the oil markets due to the industry’s inability to increase production to keep up with demand. The situation is moving rapidly however and is likely to be clarified in the next few months.
3. Peak oil and the Media
As oil approaches a hard-to-ignore $100 a barrel threshold, many of our major newspapers and news networks are starting to devote more time and front pages to the issue. Rapid increases in gasoline prices, which were lagging behind oil, have added to the interest.
While not yet ready to acknowledge that peak world oil production is imminent, last week the New York Times said “today’s surge is fundamentally different from the previous oil crises, with broad and longer-lasting global implications.” The Times goes on to say “unlike past oil shocks, which were caused by sudden interruptions in exports from the Middle East, this time prices have been rising steadily as demand for gasoline grows in developed countries, as hundreds of millions of Chinese and Indians climb out of poverty and as other developing economies grow at a sizzling pace.”
Meanwhile down in Washington, the Post sticks to its “no shortage” guns with an 1800-word, front page story that starts out “unlike earlier spikes in oil prices, which came on the heels of war in the Middle East, this latest ascent does not appear to be linked to any one conflict or to any physical shortage.” The Post concludes that “traders who treat oil like any other commodity are widely thought to be driving prices upward, bolstered by a weak dollar and money flowing out of stock markets and other investment vehicles.” No supply problems here!
Although it is impossible to characterize the positions of hundreds of newspapers and TV commentators around the globe, progress in recognizing that the world has a systemic, incurable energy problem is being made, especially in Europe where more stories and TV programs clearly present the arguments for the imminent peaking of oil production.
Further understanding of peak oil by the media probably rests with the course of oil prices over the next year. If the current surge proves to be a “spike” with oil settling back down to $70 or $80 then it will take other developments before the message of peak oil gets through. Should however, oil remain in three figures and continue to climb, it should not take long before there is general recognition that the “speculation” argument is specious and the search for the real causes of the economic troubles will begin.
4. IEA’s World Energy Outlook 2007
Last Wednesday, the International Energy Agency released its annual World Energy Outlook that forecasts global energy demand, supply and investment until 2030. On its face, this year’s edition seems to continue the IEA’s tradition of detachment from reality. Demand for energy especially from China and India is projected to double by 2030 and the world is to come up with $22 trillion to invest in new sources of energy. China will have 270 million vehicles in 2030 and world petroleum exports will have to increase from 41 million b/d to 65 million b/d.
The IEA is still saying that “world oil resources are judged to be sufficient to meet the projected growth in demand to 2030, with output becoming more concentrated in OPEC countries – on the assumption that the necessary investment is forthcoming.” At least they are throwing in the caveat that those trillions of dollars, which currently are nowhere in sight, will be a necessary ingredient to sufficient oil.
The good news in the report is that it is abundantly clear that the IEA’s “reference case” is becoming a straw man that will not happen. In fact, the IEA uses these absurdly large, “business as usual” projections to make the case that the world must change its ways or face disaster from pollution and competition for energy security.
The key judgment in this year’s report is that the next ten years will be “critical for governments globally to address these challenges as energy demand surges in the booming economies of China and India.” Finally, reality really sets in when the report opines that “a supply-side crunch in the period to 2015, involving an abrupt escalation in oil prices, cannot be ruled out.”
It is hard to say if this is really a useful document, for it takes too much time projecting and discussing virtual impossibilities. At the press conference that released the report the IEA’s Executive Director Tanaka said he shared concerns with the US that commercial oil inventories held by the world's major industrialized countries were set to fall below five-year averages this winter. He added that "stocks need to be higher, something that is in the power of producer countries to address."
5. Energy Briefs
- Brazil's state-run oil firm Petrobras said it estimates the recoverable light oil volume at its ultra-deep Tupi field at between 5 billion and 8 billion barrels, making it the country’s largest oil field and the world’s second-largest discovery during the last two decades. Production is expected to start up at 100,000 b/day by 2010 or 2011 and grow thereafter.
- A bomb damaged an oil pipeline in northern Yemen last week, halting the flow to the Hudeida export terminal on the Red Sea. The pipeline has a capacity of carrying 155,000 barrels of crude oil per day. At least six government troops and six Yemeni tribesmen were killed in a clash that followed the tribesmen's attack on an oil installation.
- Venezuela is taking steps to strengthen economic and oil industry ties to China that include additional oil production and even possible new ventures to refine crude, Venezuela’s oil minister said Friday. Venezuela wants to supply China with 1 million b/d of crude a by 2012.
- Scarcity of diesel fuel hit China’s richest cities—Beijing, Shanghai and trading ports on the east coast—which in the past have been kept well supplied. In Ningbo, a city south of Shanghai, the wait at some gas stations last week was more than three hours.
- China will rely on imported crude oil for more than half of its supplies by 2010 as economic growth drives increased demand, an official from China Petroleum & Chemical Corp. said. Imports may reach about 4.2 million barrels a day.
- India, beaten by China to more than $10bn of overseas energy assets during the past two years, plans to emulate its rival by building ports and railways in Africa to secure oil and gas fields.
- Iraq's Kurdish region has defiantly signed seven new foreign oil deals in a move sure to anger Baghdad, which opposes the unilateral sell-off of crude blocks in the absence of a national oil law.
- Angola increased production by 90,000 barrels to 1.75 million barrels a day in October, following the startup of the Greater Plutonio field. Angola has steadily increased production this year, with output 240,000 barrels a day higher than when the country joined OPEC in January. Loading schedules show Angolan output rising a further 180,000 barrels a day in the last two months of the year.
- Improved drilling technologies spurred by higher U.S. natural gas prices have led proved natural gas reserves to surpass their highest levels in 30 years, marking the eighth year in a row reserves are on the rise, according to government data. Proved reserves of natural gas increased by 3% in 2006 to more than 211 Tcf, the highest level since 1976.
- Basra's petrochemical plant, the most important in the country, has been closed down for “technical and financial reasons”—insufficient natural gas pressure plus constant power cuts—the general director of the General Company for Petrochemical Industries said on Wednesday.
- Range Fuels broke ground this week on the first full-scale biomass-to-fuel plant in the United States, in Soperton, Ga. The plant is expected to produce 20 million gallons of ethanol a year (1300 barrels/day) by chemically converting pine chips and other waste from logging operations.
- Brent oil shipments from Scotland will fall by 17% to 108 cargoes of 600,000 barrels apiece next year from 130 in 2007, according to a report prepared for the Shetland Islands Council last week. UK output has dropped 44 percent since its 1999 peak.
- Americans have consumed an average of 9.3 million barrels of gasoline a day so far this year, an increase of 0.6 percent from last year. The increasing use of ethanol, which lowers mileage, mixed into the gasoline may be part of the reason for the increased consumption. There is little indication that high prices are causing a major drop in consumption.
- Britain’s national average gasoline price topped 1 pound per liter, or about $8 a gallon, for the first time this week because of record oil prices.
- Shell’s production from the Mars field in the Gulf of Mexico has been partially curtailed, due to underwater technical problems. Production may be down as much as 150,000 b/d, compared to September’s average production of 273,459 b/d.
- The soaring price of oil has helped Russia increase its federal budget tenfold since 1999 while paying off its foreign debt and building the third-largest gold and hard-currency reserves in the world, about $425 billion.
- The US Strategic Petroleum Reserve contains about 695 million barrels of oil—enough to keep the U.S. economy running for 56 days if imports were suddenly cut off. [Ed. note: This is hypothetical; the oil could not be pumped out and delivered to refineries fast enough to offset 14 million b/d of petroleum liquid imports.] In 2005, Congress authorized expanding the reserve to 1 billion barrels. Since August, oil has been added to the reserve on a royalty-in-kind basis at about 50,000 b/d.
- Fort Chipewyan, a small aboriginal village downstream from Alberta’s massive oil sands plants, is calling for a moratorium on new projects in the region after a study found high levels of heavy metals and carcinogens in its fish and drinking water. The village says oil sands developments may be responsible for rare types of cancer in the community. The provincial government says the study is based on old data.
- Iran's nuclear program is "irreversible," according to President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad Tehran continues its defiance in the face of possible new international sanctions on the Islamic Republic.
- There is no contradiction between the International Energy Agency’s forecast of long term oil supply growth to 2030 and a “supply crunch” by 2015, according to its chief economist Fatih Birol. He insists that the short term crisis would not be caused by a fundamental shortage of oil but by entirely man-made factors.
- OPEC members are expected to take in a record $658 billion this year from their oil exports and then see their business grow by $104 billion next year, according to an EIA forecast issued on Friday.
Quote of the Week
"Every year non-OPEC production falls short of expectations.”
— Bob Tippee, editor, Oil & Gas Journal